Monday, September 8, 2014

Ebola Q & A with Dr. C.J. Peters: What My Tweeps Want to Know

Dear Friends,

The response to my Fireside Chat with Dr. C.J. Peters was even better than expected and I got a lot of great feedback from my blog readers and Twitter friends. I'd like to thank all of you for taking the time to read this blog and for engaging in such great dialogue about it. It really adds a rewarding dimension to the whole experience.

Many of you had additional questions for C.J. regarding the current Ebola epidemic. I asked him if he'd mind answering them for you here and he was happy to do so. I had to limit the questions so I selected them on a first-come, first-served basis. Several had the same or similar questions, but if I missed anything you think is critical, let me know and I will add it when I can.  Enjoy!


Our first three questions are from Dr. Ian Mackay, a virologist at the University of Queensland who is also the Keeper for both the site and blog for Virology Down Under. Dr. Mackay can be followed on Twitter: @MackayIM and I recommend it. In fact his was the first blog on my blog roll here.

Dr. Mackay: Given this outbreak is very different from previous ones - because of human factors -does what's needed to control it also have to be different?
Dr. Peters: Nobody knows. There's no indication initially that this EBOV is any more infectious than any other EBOV that we've dealt with, but it's something that should be studied using the control methods that worked with the previous outbreaks. There's no indication they wouldn't work but you gotta look.



Dr. Mackay: Following up on that question, what are the top 3 things that could be done, or done better, to contain this outbreak?
Dr. Peters: 1) More training paramedical people. 2) Provide more PPE 3) Rethink the approach. Should we be concentrating on infected areas or areas adjacent to those infected areas? We could superimpose a map of infected areas over a satellite map of the region and ring the infected areas. The adjacent areas could then be given PPE and training, not to contain it but to get on top of it. And quarantine strategy needs to change. People need to be fed and provided for. There's no panacea, they need more PPE and more equipment and currently the major worry is dealing with problems already there. An adequate response will require the whole world to step in, including the U.S. military who are more than capable of setting up field hospitals for highly infectious diseases. Also helpful would be involving anthropologists to interact with locals and help with communications - like how do you tell people what you need them to do and get them to do it?

Dr. Mackay: Have you had a chance to look at the sequence changes from the Sierra Leone genomes? If so, do any look worrying to you for phenotypic change?
Dr. Peters: We don't have the experience we need to be able to answer this. You can't tell that from the sequence unless you have experience with the given virus and with those sequence changes. We've only recently gotten to a point with influenza where we can predict what's worrisome and that's been studied by many smart people for a long time. When discussing the importance of the human genome project, people said it would provide all the words in the dictionary of human genetics. But that dictionary is only helpful if you have the definitions to go with the words. We don't have all the definitions for EBOV sequences. We just don't have the experience it takes to tell at this point.

Our next two questions are from Stephen Goldstein, ScM. Stephen is a Science News Analyst at Public Health United and a PhD student in virology at the University of Pennsylvania. He can be followed on Twitter: @stgoldst.

Stephen: Do you have any thoughts on the case fatality rate disparities between the affected countries?
Dr. Peters: No. And that's a good question. It may be a situation in which case ascertainment is not accurate, but it may be real.

Stephen: What do you make of the studies showing high seroprevalence for EBOV with no indication of illness? Subclinical infections?
Dr. Peters: I think the IFAs are totally unreliable. I've done them myself for Ebola Zaire and Reston, from monkeys and humans and they didn't tell us anything. They are just unreliable. I don't think it means that there were a bunch of subclinical infections, I think it means the test was unreliable.

(ME: C.J. and I discussed these papers for a bit, as well as his experiences with it. I was surprised to learn that even with really good controls and technique the method really isn't reliable for drawing any kind of conclusion about Ebola in this regard. )


Our next questions come from Michael Owen, a regulatory microbiologist from Washington State. Michael is a biosafety enthusiast who has compiled a nice Ebola resources webpage and he can be followed on Twitter: @owenmp.

Michael: In the field, do Ebola HCW need to collect disinfectants used to decontaminate hospital areas and used PPE? How could you do this?
Dr. Peters: Clorox is readily available and effective so they should use it when possible. People who could get exposed should have the right PPE, but if not, then they need to use what they can. Ethleen Lloyd put together a manual in 1998 to help improvise PPE for VHF in an African setting. It's available for download on the CDC website but they haven't utilized it during this epidemic. We could also face shortages of PPE for this. There were shortages with SARS and it's a possibility.

Michael: Is there a minimum time to wait between complete EVD recovery and harvesting blood from a survivor for passive therapy?
Dr. Peters: This is not known for Ebola, but blood/serum from a survivor won't help here anyway. There's no evidence that it will help, but strong evidence that it won't help. For other viruses it can be critical, such as for the arenavirus Junin, for which it is used effectively on a regular basis. But for Ebola it's just not effective. For Junin, they wait until 3 months after illness to harvest serum for therapy, but they don't know that 3 months is required, they just know that 3 months works.

(ME: I was one of the first to suggest that passive immune therapy might help with this epidemic and I was surprised at this, but now have a better understanding. Because this is currently making headlines I will be addressing it in a post soon.)

One final question I asked, on behalf of the fear-mongering doomsayers on Twitter: :Is this Ebola epidemic a threat to humanity?
Dr. Peters.: No. It may very well decimate Africa. Africa is in real trouble, but it is not a threat to humanity and it won't cause a pandemic.

ME: There. You heard that from the Quintessential Virus Hunter himself. And please don't mistake this for denial that this Ebola epidemic is a global problem...it's definitely a global problem. We've already clearly stated that this is a problem that absolutely requires a global response effort. But that's not the same as claiming it will cause a pandemic or destroy humanity. We good? Good.

A HUGE thank you to my Tweeps who came up with some great questions and an even bigger thank you to C.J., for being so willing to clarify these issues and help us understand this epidemic.

Cheers,

Heather


References

K. Mupapa, M. Massamba, K. Kibadi, K. Kuvula, A.Bwaka, M. Kipasa, R. Colebunders and J. J. Muyembe-Tamfum on behalf of theInternational Scientific and Technical Committee. Treatment of Ebola Hemorrhagic Fever with Blood Transfusions from Convalescent Patients. J InfectDis. (1999) 179 (Supplement 1): S18-S23.

Sullivan NJ1, Sanchez A, Rollin PE, Yang ZY, Nabel GJ.Development of a preventive vaccine for Ebola virus infection in primates. Nature.2000 Nov 30;408(6812):605-9.





6 comments:

  1. I miss working with C.J. Don't get me wrong, I enjoy working for Tom (Ksiazek) as well, but it was always a learning experience being around C.J.

    As usual, Heather, you've done a bang up job.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you very much Patrick. That is high praise. :) And I agree. Tom is another great guy but CJ is always willing to take the time to explain anything until you understand it. And his stories are the best.

      Delete
  2. Sorry more questions.
    The received wisdom is that fomites are not a great problem but dead bodies are extremely dangerous, Why? Is this because the sweat glands are continuing to secrete live virus post mortem (like continued hair and nail growth)? If so how long do cells continue to function after the heart and lungs have stopped delivering oxygen?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi! Nice to see you again! You are right that the bodies are sweaty, although I don't know that it's because they are still producing sweat. I don't think evaporation is very effective in that climate and in that heat they are very sweaty. Also, dead bodies keep releasing fluids for quite a while after death, and those can pool within the body. Then when handled, these fluids can get...pushed around or out. I 'm not sure about cell function after death. I think skin cells might continue to grow for a bit, but I'm no expert there.

      Delete
  3. i cant still believe that there are people out there dying of heartbreak or scammed by other spell casters,i contacted so many spell caster but non could help me bring my ex boyfriend back until i contacted Dr.SABU and explained my situation to him and then seek his help but to my greatest surprise he told me that he will help me with my case and here i am now celebrating because my Boyfriend has change totally for good. He always want to be by me and can not do anything without my present. i am really enjoying my marriage, what a great celebration. i will keep on testifying on the internet because Dr.SABU is truly a real spell caster.his email:drsabuspelltemple@gmail.com any heartbreak i will advice you to contact Dr.SABU Because in my own situation he did a very great job for me by bringing back my ex Boyfriend without wasting time and since then my relationship has been perfect and protected by his great power.or cell whatsapp number+2347057624993 So better contact him now web/site:https://drsabuspelltemple.wixsite.com/dr-sabu

    ReplyDelete
  4. Marriage was meant to be Better or for Worse,which i have always believed and keyed into. I am Mrs Alexis Maleah from North Carolina,USA.I want to use this opportunity in thanking god for using doctor prince in restoring my lost marriage back. I have been in sadness and sorrow for more than a year now without being with the one i love, i tried all my possible best to make sure i make my husband happy but it never seems to work out well it was like am doing everything in vain but all thanks to doctor prince for coming to change all my worries and sadness to Joy. i knew the great man when i read some wonderful reviews about him on how he has helped a lot of people on their relationship problem,i was also on the page relationship rules,on Facebook when i saw some one giving great testimonies about him again,immediately i decided to contact him,after contacting him he told me not to worry that within 48 hours everything would be sorted out i keyed into his words so much because i believed he can't fail me and i sent him all my details. Truly doctor prince never failed me,my husband who left me for a year came back to me in a twinkle of an eye. My husband and i have been living contentedly since this spell caster reunited us together with his love spells. Thank you very much sir prince for your powerful spells. expressions are not sufficient to say thank you. here is his email address for any one who is suffering from any of this problem (1)How to win a lottery(2)How to get your lost lover back(3)How to get rich(4)How to make men/women run after you(5)How To get Promoted in your office(6)How to get a visa(7)How to get your lost money back(8)How to win a court case(9)How to get rid of all your sickness and disease(10)How to get the magic ring,please contact doctor prince today at DR.PRINCEARATAABRAHAM@GMAIL.COM you can also Whatsapp him on +2348163241499 God Bless.

    ReplyDelete